Home Ratings & Reviews

Top 10 Mild Cigars According to YOU

So I decided to tabulate in a spreadsheets the feedback you guys gave in my other thread about mild cigars. Here is the Top 10, followed by number of votes for each. I must say I was not surprised at all with the Top 3 and the big difference between them and the rest. Here is the list - http://wbfiller.com/top-10-mild-cigars-according-to-cigar-com-forum-members/

Comments

  • sightunseensightunseen Posts: 2,130
    Nooooo Cabaiguan didn't place.
  • xmacroxmacro Posts: 3,402
    I'd put the Monty White first and the Perdomo 10th Anniv above the RP Connie, but otherwise a pretty good list - definitely agree every cigar on that list is a really good mild smoke.
  • phobicsquirrelphobicsquirrel Posts: 7,349
    I like the monte whites, they would be my top one I guess.
  • stephen_hannibalstephen_hannibal Posts: 4,317
    Guess there's no love for the Gran Habano #1 Connecticut.

  • HaybletHayblet Posts: 2,430 ✭✭✭
    stephen_hannibal:
    Guess there's no love for the Gran Habano #1 Connecticut.

    I like that one and the C.com Purple Label
  • Renaissance_ManRenaissance_Man Posts: 972
    Yeah, all votes bellow third spot are really equal so it's kind of "Top 3 plus lots of 4th places" list :)... I however don't really get it how the nub conny is number 2... I should give it another try - first one I had didn't impress me much...
  • phobicsquirrelphobicsquirrel Posts: 7,349
    stephen_hannibal:
    Guess there's no love for the Gran Habano #1 Connecticut.

    3siglos is a goodie.
  • j0z3rj0z3r Posts: 9,403
    stephen_hannibal:
    Guess there's no love for the Gran Habano #1 Connecticut.

    I'd definitely put the GH #1 above Verdadero, RP Conn. and Nub Conn....none of those three would be in my personal top ten mild cigars though.
  • HaybletHayblet Posts: 2,430 ✭✭✭
    I'm really surprised I'm the only one who suggested Ccom's purple label
  • kuzi16kuzi16 Posts: 14,616 ✭✭✭✭
    im not surprised that my favorite mild cigar didnt place....
    i only have met one other person that has had one.


    ...its their favorite mild stick too.
  • stephen_hannibalstephen_hannibal Posts: 4,317
    What was you favorite Kuzi?

  • kuzi16kuzi16 Posts: 14,616 ✭✭✭✭
    original release AVO 22.

  • Renaissance_ManRenaissance_Man Posts: 972
    kuzi16:
    original release AVO 22.

    Yeah - there was a long list of just "1" votes... In fact - let me paste it here (the first three actually got 2 so maybe Cabaiguan should oust the Turk - its just alphabetical arrangement by Excel anyway):
    Cabaiguan
    Rocky Patel Signature
    Oliva Connecticut Reserve
    Joya De Nicaragua Clasico
    Camacho Liberty '08
    Gran Habano #1 Connecticut
    Cugine 
    Gurkha Symphony
    Romeo & Julieta 1875 Cedaro Deluxe #2
    CAO Gold Maduro
    AVO 22
    AVO #2 (is this one different than Kuzi's 22?)
    NUB Maduro
    Ashton Classic
    Carlos Torano Reserva Selecta
    La Aroma de Cuba Edicion Especial
    Indian Tabac Limited Reserve
    Cigar.com Purple Label
    Fonseca
    Cuesta Rey
    Alec Bradley Occidental Reserve
    Cigar.com Cameroon Label
    Graycliff G2

    I think what this all proves though is the vast differences in preferences among cigar smoker! I guess it really is true - "one man's garbage is another man's treasure"! And all those sticks have merit - otherwise I am sure nobody would like them at ALL...
  • Poker_SlobPoker_Slob Posts: 1,138 ✭✭✭✭
    Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.
  • kuzi16kuzi16 Posts: 14,616 ✭✭✭✭
    Renaissance_Man:
    [ AVO 22
    AVO #2 (is this one different than Kuzi's 22?)
    very different.
  • fla-gypsyfla-gypsy Posts: 3,024 ✭✭
    I tried a Padilla Hybrid this morning at 0530 and thought it was pretty good. I am not a fan of mild and not sure this is really a mild but it's as close as I am going to get.
  • HeavyHeavy Posts: 1,591 ✭✭✭
    I think i mentioned the purple in that thread (I think i did anyway). I've only had a couple and it's been a while ago, but I remember being surprised at how much I liked it.
  • HeavyHeavy Posts: 1,591 ✭✭✭
    Hayblet:
    I'm really surprised I'm the only one who suggested Ccom's purple label
    ^^above post was referring this this
  • Renaissance_ManRenaissance_Man Posts: 972
    Heavy:
    I think i mentioned the purple in that thread (I think i did anyway). I've only had a couple and it's been a while ago, but I remember being surprised at how much I liked it.
    Yeah - I think yours was the only vote for this that I saw in the other thread... I have never tried any other labels but the Brazilian. If they come close to quality however - I'll def. give the purple a try...
  • MrBuhlMrBuhl Posts: 4

    phobicsquirrel:
    I like the monte whites, they would be my top one I guess.

    +3 on the Monte Whites for number one -

  • MrMokeMrMoke Posts: 321
    Poker Slob:
    Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.
    I'll 2nd that, it is very interesting!! thasnxs for putting iit together :)
  • Renaissance_ManRenaissance_Man Posts: 972
    MrMoke:
    Poker Slob:
    Thanks for taking the time to do this. This is very interesting indeed.
    I'll 2nd that, it is very interesting!! thasnxs for putting iit together :)
    Not much done here boys! I wanted to get an idea for myself - its why I asked in the forum. This is simply taking 10 minutes to sort through the responses and putting it online. I must say - if you ever need a list like this or need an answer on what to try - Cigar.com forum members have been the most helpful and responsive BOTLs I have ever seen/met! Cheers!
Sign In or Register to comment.