Ratings & Reviews

Discussion List

• Halfwheel’s Review hits me hard

  1.6K views 80 comments 2 points Most recent by Amos_Umwhat February 11
• Evaluating Aged Cigars

  914 views 47 comments 9 points Most recent by Vision January 29
• Punch Cigars

  86 views 2 comments 0 points Most recent by Rdp77 October 2025
• Age Verification and Customer Service

  154 views 12 comments -4 points Most recent by rsherman24 September 2025
• Ava maria and man o war

  247 views 21 comments 0 points Most recent by ShawnOL August 2025
• Oh The Comments

  105 views 4 comments 0 points Most recent by Rdp77 July 2025
• Hawks' Simple Reviews

  325 views 12 comments 5 points Most recent by memento_mori July 2025
• Alec Bradley

  65 views 4 comments -3 points Most recent by dirtdude July 2025
• My Father The Judge Grand Robusto... #1 Cigar... Really??

  2.3K views 29 comments 0 points Most recent by Vision April 2025
• El Mago Flight

  122 views 2 comments 7 points Most recent by Itsfine April 2025
• Minato-esque reviews

  403 views 17 comments 16 points Most recent by Vision March 2025
• Need a new non peppery medium to full strength recommendation $10-$20.

  189 views 8 comments 0 points Most recent by Itsfine January 2025
• Diesel Whiskey Row

  332 views 13 comments 0 points Most recent by d_blades October 2024
• Diesel Unlimited

  377 views 16 comments 1 point Most recent by PhilM111 October 2024
• Surprised this hasn't been mentioned here yet. Cuban Cigars are illegal again to bring into the US

  1.6K views 65 comments 4 points Most recent by Amos_Umwhat October 2024
• A real man's reviews

  2.3K views 121 comments 6 points Most recent by Vision September 2024
• Martel's Marvelous Musings on Magnificent Miasmas of Merit

  4.9K views 539 comments 0 points Most recent by peter4jc January 2024
• SOMM

  112 views 3 comments 5 points Most recent by memento_mori December 2023
• Onyx Reserve

  151 views 20 comments 0 points Most recent by memento_mori November 2023
• The Light Of Ybor

  116 views 3 comments 0 points Most recent by GenerosityLeadership November 2023
• Pryme by Alec Bradley 200X

  63 views 5 comments 0 points Most recent by Wylaff November 2023
• Cigar Oasis replacement, the inkbird IHC-200-WIFI

  167 views 6 comments 4 points Most recent by Yakster October 2023
• Havoc by AJ Fernandez

  208 views 4 comments 7 points Most recent by Hawks August 2023
• Five best and 2 worst AJs

  613 views 16 comments 4 points Most recent by KingoftheCove July 2023
• Good Coffee flavored cigar?

  Answered ✓ 3K views 18 comments 0 points Most recent by CommanderDuke_1 July 2023
• Penn Standard?

  1.4K views 11 comments 0 points Most recent by BrianLD66 June 2023
• Boveda Smart Sensor Bluetooth Hygrometer

  3.7K views 18 comments 3 points Most recent by Yakster February 2023
• Acid Def Sea

  181 views 5 comments 1 point Most recent by PuertoRicoShawn January 2023
• RP DBS

  82 views 0 comments 9 points Started by Krieg December 2022
• Ron White

  182 views 0 comments 7 points Started by Itsfine December 2022