My Father The Judge Grand Robusto... #1 Cigar... Really??

ajmorlanne

Well the My Father The Judge Grand Robusto was named 2024 cigar of the year by CA. Maybe old news, but I lead a sheltered life. So has anybody tried these? Are they all that? They're sold out EVERYWHERE! Or are we taking newbie noobs just blindly guided by CA again? Cause honestly never heard much about them. Thanx for your feedback and or review. Get home.

Vision

@ajmorlanne said:
Well the My Father The Judge Grand Robusto was named 2024 ADVERTISING of the year by CA.

FIFY

I disagree with 90% of that list this year.

rsherman24

They are no HalfWheel

VegasFrank

That cigar is different this year. JK, it isn't. Apparently the melanio is the same tho.

VegasFrank

Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

Vision

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

VegasFrank

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Just relax your jaw buddy

Vision

@VegasFrank said:

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Just relax your jaw buddy

Are you saying... don't tense up, it only makes it worse?

OutdoorsSmoke_21191

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Just relax your jaw buddy

Are you saying... don't tense up, it only makes it worse?

You sound like my proctologist and/or my prison cell mate 😂😂

Vision

@OutdoorsSmoke_21191 said:

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Just relax your jaw buddy

Are you saying... don't tense up, it only makes it worse?

You sound like my proctologist and/or my prison cell mate 😂😂

Learned it from you good buddy..... you're wise beyond your years.

Wylaff

I read those out of order and thought your proctologist was telling you to relax your jaw...

Patrickbrick

Man goes to prison. His cell mate asked “do you want to be the husband, or the wife?” Man replies “I guess I’ll be the husband”. Cell mate replies “good, get over here and suck your wife's di*k!”

Patrickbrick

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Become? I’ve been heavily into cigars and the “hobby” (what we tell ourselves for justification) for at least 12 years, Cigar Aficionado has been this way that whole time. Since that’s when I started paying attention, it definitely goes back further.

Vision

@Patrickbrick said:

@Vision said:

@VegasFrank said:
Sold out everywhere because it's #1, not because it's so popular...or, it's so popular because it's #1, not because it's the best. Good smoke. Try it when you can buy it. But it's always been overpriced by 1 or 2 bucks.

At 5x60 Donkeydong I will not be trying this vitola. Zero percent chance I ever buy this. What a fawking farce these ratings have become.

Become? I’ve been heavily into cigars and the “hobby” (what we tell ourselves for justification) for at least 12 years, Cigar Aficionado has been this way that whole time. Since that’s when I started paying attention, it definitely goes back further.

When I started you could look at the list and say "Sure" or "ok I get that" but now it's overtly obvious.

Patrickbrick

Has been for over a decade

peter4jc

Your mom's been over for a decade.

Patrickbrick

Not quite a decade yet, but a few months away.

IndustMech

@peter4jc said:
Your mom's been over for a decade.

Okay, Alan

peter4jc

@IndustMech said:

@peter4jc said:
Your mom's been over for a decade.

Okay, Alan

@IndustMech

Don't you mean Andy?

Vision

@peter4jc said:

@IndustMech said:

@peter4jc said:
Your mom's been over for a decade.

Okay, Alan

@IndustMech

Don't you mean Andy?

We need a guy named Alan or Andy around here.

Rdp77

We have an Alan

Vision

@Rdp77 said:
We have an Alan

Rusty..... did you take me seriously?

Rdp77

Yakster

We have an Allan

Vision

I just copied John..... that was the joke.

Amos_Umwhat

My goodness this cigar has provided a lot of discussion.

peter4jc

Discussers gonna discuss.