Home› General Discussion

Newb ?

fishndude3fishndude3 Posts: 22
in General Discussion
Ive read alot about coolidors and have been looking for a small one that fits the bill. I have a smallish styro one that has an awesone seal, and the size would fit the bill. My ? is , would this material work? I never read where anyone is using styrofoam? I have added some Spanish Ceder pieces, humidifier beads, and let it sit. It is reading right at 70% ? Would this work?

Comments

  • danielzreyesdanielzreyes Posts: 8,769 ✭✭✭✭✭
    People have used anywhere from zip loc bags to ammo cases as humidors. If it has a good enough seal and it can hold humidity to where you want it, then absolutely.
    "It's plume, bro. Nothing to worry about. Got any Opus?" The suppose to be DZR
  • Bob_LukenBob_Luken Posts: 10,536 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Sounds like it would work except I'd be concerned about the odor. Every styrofoam cooler I've ever been around has had an odor. The newer they are the stronger the odor. I would make sure to stick my head down in there after the lid has been shut for a while and smell it. If there's any "styrofoam" smell at all I'd pass. Those odors would be absorbed by your cigars. You can get a plastic Coleman Xtreme 28 quart for less than 20 bucks at walmart and it makes a very nice small coolidor. I have two of them. One stores boxes and the other has 12.5" x 7.5" spanish cedar trays stacked for loose singles. And if I ever get to where I don't store cigars in them,.............they are really nice coolers for beer and whatever.
  • fishndude3fishndude3 Posts: 22
    The Odor issue is the concern for me. It isnt aweful, but there is a distinct mild odor.
  • Bob_LukenBob_Luken Posts: 10,536 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Just a mild odor huh? Maybe it's so mild that you wouldn't notice. But I still wouldn't risk it. I've never heard of anybody using a styrofoam cooler either. Maybe it's because of the odor problem. Would you be ok with your cigars having just a mild styrofoam taste? LOL
  • RainRain Posts: 8,958 ✭✭✭
    Bob Luken:
    Just a mild odor huh? Maybe it's so mild that you wouldn't notice. But I still wouldn't risk it. I've never heard of anybody using a styrofoam cooler either. Maybe it's because of the odor problem. Would you be ok with your cigars having just a mild styrofoam taste? LOL
    Sounds like a Gurkha ;)
  • allsmokedupallsmokedup Posts: 751 ✭✭
    36 qt coolers are $20-30 or so at Walmart. Zip locs are even cheaper. Don't risk compromising your cigars over something so trivial.
  • Bob_LukenBob_Luken Posts: 10,536 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Rain:
    Bob Luken:
    Just a mild odor huh? Maybe it's so mild that you wouldn't notice. But I still wouldn't risk it. I've never heard of anybody using a styrofoam cooler either. Maybe it's because of the odor problem. Would you be ok with your cigars having just a mild styrofoam taste? LOL
    Sounds like a Gurkha ;)
    You mean Gurkhas are similar to styrofoam in that styofoam also does weird things when you light it on fire?

    (Hope fishndude3 isn't a big Gurkha fan. If he is, he should be made aware that we have a Gurkha anti-fan club chapter here.)
  • edelrionycedelrionyc Posts: 361 ✭✭✭
    In my opinon, anything with a seal that is odorless and can keep your humidity in place works. Whether it be a humidor, cooler, zip lock bag, plastic food containers etc....
  • brianetz1brianetz1 Posts: 4,134 ✭✭✭
    allsmokedup:
    36 qt coolers are $20-30 or so at Walmart. Zip locs are even cheaper. Don't risk compromising your cigars over something so trivial.
    i agree on this one.....if you need a cooler, you have hundreds of dollars to thousands of dollars in cigars that you want to store. Why would you risk affecting the natural flavors on the cigars by putting it in a styrofoam container when a suitable replacement costs under $50.
  • fishndude3fishndude3 Posts: 22
    Ok Ok Ok! Nixt that idea. Not worth it. Ive got another 50 count I was going to give a freind, hes just gonna have to wait till I decide what Im going to do? Ill put as many as I can in there and bag the rest. Thanks everyone for your help.
  • MVW67MVW67 Posts: 5,592 ✭✭✭✭
    fishndude3:
    Ok Ok Ok! Nixt that idea. Not worth it. Ive got another 50 count I was going to give a freind, hes just gonna have to wait till I decide what Im going to do? Ill put as many as I can in there and bag the rest. Thanks everyone for your help.
    Or you could check at your local stores and pick up large rubber sealed plastic containers, I have a couple that'll hold about 100+ sticks
    Life is too short, live it like no tomorrow...
  • fishndude3fishndude3 Posts: 22
    If i use a cooler or rubbermaid, do i put some spanish ceder in there? If so, how much?
  • MVW67MVW67 Posts: 5,592 ✭✭✭✭
    You can, I just have boxes, but not required. In Rubbermaid I have none
    Life is too short, live it like no tomorrow...
  • brianetz1brianetz1 Posts: 4,134 ✭✭✭
    fishndude3:
    If i use a cooler or rubbermaid, do i put some spanish ceder in there? If so, how much?
    glad mike confirmed for me, but i think the cedar is just to satisfy the aroma of a humidor. I know a few people that just have them in plastic bags in a cooler or rubermaid.
  • fishndude3fishndude3 Posts: 22
    Thanks guys. This place is great!
  • allsmokedupallsmokedup Posts: 751 ✭✭
    brianetz1:
    fishndude3:
    If i use a cooler or rubbermaid, do i put some spanish ceder in there? If so, how much?
    glad mike confirmed for me, but i think the cedar is just to satisfy the aroma of a humidor. I know a few people that just have them in plastic bags in a cooler or rubermaid.


    The cedar will absorb moisture and make the environment more stable than with just the humdifiers alone. Also, with just plastic it is very easy to over-humdify a container.
Sign In or Register to comment.