Make A Wish (read first post)

avengethis said:

Warped (I have only had the Flor Del Valle)
Crowned Heads - Double W, Le Careme, Black Dog
La Palina - Pasha, TAA 16
Foundation Tabernacle
Tat TAA 12, 13, 14
Viaje Juntos, Super Shots
La Barba Red

kuzi16 said:

Make a wish is the inverse of the Pay it Forward. Here is how this works:
1) person “A” says “I would like to try these cigars: x,y,z..."
person “B” (who has that cigar in his humi) says I will give you that cigar.
III) person “B” sends person “A” three of those cigars to try.
4) person “B” now gets to wish for a cigar to try.
...

EDIT 9-10-12: this rule is here because of the rule further down about getting three of the cigar. the entire point of this thread is to have a good shake at a cigar you have not had before. one cigar does not give it a fair shake. three does. if i wish for LAdC Mi Amor, i should get 3 of them to give it a fair shot in case one is a dud. 

I think a lot of people have misunderstood this part. It should be 3 of the same cigar, that is one of the ones on the wishlist, allowing them a chance to actually try it. Not three different ones from the wish list.

I will update my list as well since I have actually gotten the opportunity to try a few of these.

matkn293 said:

I dont think anyone has thought about that rule or suggestion for a very long time.  It seems these days it is trying to fulfill a majority of a wish list and I think that that line of thinking is ok. The rules of the game so to speak have changed and adapted. 

I agree with this too.  For me I would rather fulfill a wish if I have a handful of them, vs sending three of one of them.  this is just my thinking and is my opinion, but I also try to send at least two of one of the sticks on the list, this is out of respect to the original rule plus it is nice to have two of something.  I do understand that this is not always possible or within reason (so again just my thinking) I will send what I have off the list.  I don't want to see this game die however, so if it needs to adapted to keep it going I say go for it.  It does seem that the same people are jumping in, not to many participants.   

@avengethis I believe I have some on your list. I will confirm tomorrow. You're going to Chicago correct? If so I'll bring them with me

Alright I got your wish covered then. 

CCs- Bolivar, H Upmann, Cohiba Siglo IV
Liga Privada T52, #9
Davidoff- any
Ezra Zion chocolate porter
Black Label Trading Co- any
LFD La Nox

i know there's more so I'll add ti the list as I think of them if these aren't do able. 

Sounds good D-run

I got H Upmann cc. And lanox and Ligas. Plus a couple cold ones and shlt. I'll bring to da herf. Chicago style pizza to boot!  Bam!

Seeing as how cold it's going to be in Chicago this weekend can I add fur coat or case of hot hands to my list?

Wish away diver boy @skydiverD. 
@matkn293 nothing is ever just an innocent smack down with you. 

I can't wish until I actually deliver the goods.  I could die in a freak shower accident.....Or I could decide to smoke them myself, today before the herf..... So I'll hold off til after the herf... Just in case. 

You going to make a wish big guy or talk about fishing all day?

I will definitely enjoy my fulfilled wish. Thanks again @skydiverD!

9405803699300377452228